Happy New Year! I pray each of you has encountered the Lord anew in this Christmas season! Following the October and December Rapp Ups, this is the third installment of my reflections on Pope Leo’s educational priorities in his letter “Drawing New Maps of Hope”. 

The Holy Father says: “Technologies must serve, not replace, the person; they must enrich the learning process, not impoverish relationships and communities…Let us educate in a judicious use of technology and of AI, placing the person before the algorithm and harmonizing technical, emotional, social, spiritual and ecological intelligence.”  

I think what the Holy Father is stating here aligns with, and challenges, the paradigm surrounding technology at St. James. Various technologies are tools, and tools are helpful when used with their intended purpose by capable people.  However, as technologies become more powerful and widely-available, such as the democratization of artificial intelligence in the last two-plus years, it requires a holistic revisiting of priorities and preparation. 

By artificial intelligence, I mean it in the narrow, commonly-used sense of generative AI, more specifically large language models like Chat GPT or Gemini. As a technology, it need not be feared outright, and we will enhance our instruction related to AI in our Intro to Computer Science classes as well as offering a new elective (Cybersecurity and AI Literacy) next year. We will also be speaking to all students about AI and the new AI policy at St. James at the start of this semester.

Having said that, St. James Academy’s fundamental posture towards artificial intelligence is informed by our mission, and we believe the use of artificial intelligence by students for schoolwork is in the vast majority of cases contrary to our ends. 

The arguments I hear for embracing AI in schools generally fall into three categories: A, it’s not going away, and to fight it is a waste of energy; B, many (if not most or all) of our students will need to use AI in their jobs someday, and we need to prepare them for that; and C, many adults already use AI in our jobs, and so it is hypocritical to deny students the advantages of tools we use freely. 

My simplest response to A, B, and C is that two questions need to be answered: What is the purpose of AI? And what is the purpose of school? 

The purpose of AI is to help us do most things more efficiently and often better than we could do on our own. This capacity at least has the possibility of being good and helping advance noble causes. 

The purpose of school, however, is not about getting things done; it’s about what happens to the person while they’re doing things. 

To use an analogy, Chat GPT is like a moving sidewalk at an airport: it helps get you where you’re going faster and easier, or you can just let it do the walking for you so you can use the time to focus on something else. The work we do at school, however, is meant to be more like a treadmill. It is a tool to sharpen the person, to provide friction against which one can test natural capacities, strengthen what is within them, build endurance and strength and muscle. Yes, it might be boring at times. You may not always like it or want to do it. And if one thought the purpose was to get somewhere else, then being on a treadmill would surely seem like a pointless or even idiotic use of time. 

Which is precisely why we speak so often about what our purpose is here. It’s why Mr. Tylicki talks about our mission every time he speaks, why most of my Rapp Ups talk about the fact that who students become is more important than what they’re able to do. We are not here just to help students get somewhere else. That is certainly a desirable byproduct of what we do, and it would be imprudent not to have an eye toward the future while going through high school. Rather, we are here to help them become a certain kind of person, regardless of where they go next.

The question of AI is a perfect case study of priorities. The primary goal of St. James is forming the hearts and minds of young people to know Truth, choose good, and live virtuously. The secondary goal (or byproduct) is a successful future. AI might make the second goal easier or faster to get to (at least in the short term). But the first thing should be first, and it is something AI cannot do for us. Embracing AI without considering the consequences, integrating it without contemplation, is putting second things first. When we do that, things go wrong. 

No technology can know something for you. Only persons can know. No technology can choose for you. Only persons can choose. And while we can cede the responsibility to know and choose well to technologies that imitate these capacities, it will always be a mimicry, and we risk impoverishing our very selves in that choice. 

AI is an extraordinarily efficient, effective, and productive tool. If education were like the process of building something from scratch, we would be fools not to embrace this tool to see how far it could take us. 

But education is more like gardening than building. We aren’t starting from scratch. We are accepting these children and their humanity as a gift from God, and trying to cooperate with the nature of the thing given so that it may grow and flourish.

Gardening is slow, inefficient, difficult work, much of which is outside of the control of the gardeners. So is teaching. So is parenting. 

But when done right, something arresting in its beauty and delightful in its power happens: we see something become what it was always meant to be. 

What a great and holy task. May we never forget it, and may we never cede the responsibility given to us to anything or anyone else.

Your brother in Christ, 

Shane